
From THE LANGSTON HUGHES READER, p. 101, © 1957.
This poem by Langston Hughes grew out of conditions in New York City’s Harlem in the 1930’s. In graphic terms it describes the escalation of anger and frustration that tenants experienced trying to get landlords to make basic repairs. It is structured like an old time blues song until the final verse where the rhythm changes.
Charley Noble
My favorite Poet
My question is, why didn't the teacher read it, Blacker? Oh, was the teacher, white? Non the less, the poem is written about a Black person, by a Black man. That in it's self should have been enough.
Where is that east coast accent we hear when 'New Yorkers' are talking( if you want to put it in context from 'My' perspective)? Dialect or Accent is the question as to how this poem should be read? Hummm, I wonder at what age level should one be 'at'( language a urban kid would use) to articulate such a concept( if that kind of 'concept' has been or was 'being' taught) OR, since they were in Virginia, was a 'Southerner' expression expected?
'We be jiv'in U or what not' you'd think?
My mother was from Georgia, father ( we called him Dad de' , like in Daddy!) and I grew-up in Indianapolis and as my peers would say 'Talk White'( I'm a university administrator for more than 3 decades). Now how should I read this poem? How would you? By the way, what is 'BLACKER'?
It sucks but that teacher should not be under investigation unless there was more to it. The truth is, the poem is written in dialect of the time. Much like poems from James Whitcomb Riley. Now.. should she have picked on him? No- she should have read it herself. But poetry interpretation is all about invoking emotion while reading.. and you can't do that, nor does the poem flow- if you use proper English.
"COMMENTER"My issue is the fact that she questioned him, "Well you're black right?". Maybe the kid didn't know how to talk in that dialect? Would she have picked a white kid & asked him to use that dialect as well?
"nphilanas" That was stupid on her part and shows a complete lack of common sense and reality. Black history can't cover her.. but ignorance will..
I too, heard about the teacher and wanted to read the poem. If she had wanted it to sound as if a certain person was reading it, she should have discussed it, and told the student “why” she felt it was appropriate to read the poem that way. However, she came across in a very negative way, and insulted the student.
When I came to this point in the poem:
Police! Police!
Come and get this man!
He's trying to ruin the government
And overturn the land!
the statement sent shivers down my spine, as this reflects on how many whites, especially in politics, see our current president. The republicans want to take us back to the “old days”, thus they are turning back the clock on women’s rights, voting rights, equality of wage, and even child labor. In addition, many have stated they want us to go back to different times. This paragraph is all telling of the problems we still have in this not “united” states. They might say it is not about race, but, the hate that many spew, including Limbaugh, Beck, Palin (who said Obama wants us to go back to the 19th century..”For real?”), and others have, shows it is about race, and that paragraph has very powerful and telling words! The other day, Michael Steel, a black man, commented on Romney’s trying to fit in with the accent of the state, and he actually said that he would have to speak “Ebonics” if he went to Harlem. I was shocked, and amazed (should not be, as he is a republican), that he, as a black man of power, would assume all people in Harlem spoke that way. Still work to be done to get us into the 18th century.
Ironically enough, I could imagine this becoming the ballad of a lot of southern states right now. The federal government expects them to pay taxes while refusing to fix a porous border.
I just found this site as I wanted to find out about this Langston Hughes poem - which I didn't know. It is making headlines as a student in Falls Church, VA was reprimanded for not reading this poem "black enough". I had to smile as I came from a poor 'white' town and this poem could have been written for one of those families as well! Dishonest landlords come in all colors, shapes and sizes and are awful to everyone and anyone.
This poem has a subtle racist face to it. It is a true reflection of how much misunderstanding of what humanity is all about. It also shows how inhumane the person with more can be.
great!!

On first impression, no matter who you are , if you have been a tenant you know that this poem is true. No matter how things change the more they stay the same. You don't need to be black or in New York to live those things. Joyce White
This poem tells the story of time.

no complaints pall - enjoyed - scared me a bit - but thts cool![]()
I like his Jess B. Semple stories too. What a Master! ![]()
DM
I think this would make a good rap. Hughes was a man ahead of his time in many ways.
Jim
I remember hearing about this. I'm sure it sounds great in the blues way! black people were treated so bad then. I'm glad things are getting better now that Landlord's have to follow laws that provide for the poor.
![]()
The plight of poor tenants in the 1930's is now being revisited with the plight of middle class tenants in 2011. We're all going down the same drain!
Charley Noble
I think this is great wish i had a landlord to send it to
I may send this to MY landlord, lol
i liked that this poem had a historical root and that it used a sort of slang. it was a very fun read.
Cool!