Ditch the ads, upload images and much more - upgrade today from 5.95/month!
Read Contests Groups Learn Forums Store Help
 

If it's a review that you want...


Poem one then, "Echoes of war...centuries of blight". To analyse such a long and multilayerd poem such as this one is never going to be a small task as there is simply so much one can comment on. It's difficult to choose where to start commenting on the brilliance yet for the sake of the competion I shall 'have a go'.
I enjoyed the unstructured flow of the poem, irregular stanza lengths and sporadic rhyming schemes serve to reflect in the structure the chaotic nature of war itself. I personaly think that some of the stanza's were overly long and could have been broken down. The reader is swept along and never quite able to stop and consider the impact of the language and what amazing language use it is!
For example in stanza two
'then sent him whole and healthy off to fight,
 but Got back telegrams and body bags,
Some shiny medals and some folded flags,
plus monstrous gaping holes left in thier souls,'
These few lines are a touching comment on the fate of those left behind awating the dreaded knock upon the front door but I feel it get's swallowed by the rest of the stanza. incidentaly I think the poem could benefit from a little tweaking of syntax here and there to tighten up the lines. In the example above there are too many 'ands' for my liking. Also the word monstrous is pretty much unessacary as that abstract cannot adequately describe the horror that those parents are going through. The images such as the body bags and shiny medals hold enough impact without trying to condense the emotions into one word such as monstrous. I'd suggest something a bit more like this...
'then sent him whole and healthy off to fight,
but got back telegrams, a body bag,
some shiny medals and some folded flags,
little to fill the gaping holes left in thier souls.'
Of course thats just a suggestion!
I liked how you honed in on different facets, the children, the wives, the parents and the veterans all deserve equal recognition for thier suffering. linking the marital vows was stroke of genius, the paralell's between marching down the asile and marching into war are heart rending. A strcualist would have a feild day commenting on the use of binary oppositions in this poem however I'm going to move my ramblings onto 'Totally stumped by it all!'
The title at first seemed slightly comic to me, off the cuff, yet after reading the poem that assumption was truely shattered. There is no comedy here. Drawing a link with 'Echoes of war' where there was a strong religous theme of heaven and the afterlife, I feel what 'Totally stumped' creates is a living purgatory. Neither dead nor truely alive, unable to govern their own fates, most would call that a hell on earth. The pill is not sugard here and I applaud you for that. Comments on "scar tissue for testicles" and the throb of "imagined" limbs forces the reader to examine uncomfortable facts. It's easier to pretend that our war veterans sit in an armchair filled room somewhere regaling eachother with tales of thier bravery and comparing battle scars but the image you have created of tiny hospital like rooms and unseen tears is much closer to the mark.
Time is money and I shall have to cut my ramblings short. A final word to say that both these poems examine a difficult topic with a realistic yet sympatheic eye. Someone at least cares for the plight of those touched by wars which are happening right now, not just in history, today our brothers and our fathers fight in Iraq and Afganistan and we change the channel when the news comes on. We are desensitised and we need to have literature such as this which makes us uncomfortable, which speaks without restraint of the horror of war, to make us sit up and take notice of what is happening around us. A reverential bow to the wordsmith who has once again given us something brilliant.

Author notes

The FeliX

A contest entry

Please tell me what you think

    : , Your review:

    Comment Suggestion: What is your your first impression?
    Line numbers  • Invite them to read
    : no Cost: 0 free left 0 points, You have (?)

Comments


  • toomysterious
    August 29, 2008
    Edit | Reply
    Wonderful commentary here, and good analysis of the poems. Good luck.


  • heartnsoul
    August 26, 2008
    Edit | Reply
    An outstanding review on a topic that is hard to read and swallow for the common man. And just as equally hard for those who have lived it to write, much less talk about. You've articulated much of what I felt but just couldn't find the way I would have liked to express it.
    Good luck in the contest.
    Michelle


  • artis
    August 26, 2008

    Edit | Reply

    Excellent review, and yes, there are binary oppositions, and too many ands, and overusage of monstrous words. but I have read this work many times at P.O.W. and M.I.A vigils and at the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier, and watched the common man, the soldier

    weep openly at its convoluted message...so I am loathe to change it, being a common man and former soldier myself. But I have had editors redo it for me, in the various publications it has haunted. These are a pieces meant to be read aloud, and followed by bagpipes playing "Amazing Grace", and then Taps. Perhaps you struck a chord of such note, when you mention how hard a task it would be to write a poetic reply to this kind of poem. Far too many hide from the agony of war, and what it does to the human condition. You may be my only entry, and I thank you for your courage in tackling such topics, much like the 1,000 points may be my additional thanks for your time.~~~Artis