Ditch the ads, upload images and much more - upgrade today from 5.95/month!
Read Contests Groups Learn Forums Store Help
 

Girl With The Guitar

She wore green,
like                maiden,
                              Woven,
                                    cloth
      over little breasts
            and slim,
                      heart-shaped
              corset.
  But not like these.
              From gentle hands
her sleeves were rolled up.
    She played strings.
              But not on the lap
      of plenty
            full blue skirts
and not as the cameo
    profile of porcelain
not French-braided
    or handpainted
    but for under her
eyes, which looked down,
      lined with Rhapsody blue,
          counting time.
She sketched
    reverently
but with a bright orange pick
            and with fingernails,
    like moons, like blisters, bent.
              She wore no perfume
                  except for the pine trees
  dripping from the guitar.

Author notes

*POW* The theme is sort of a comparison between a girl of today and one of long ago.
I commented 'A Passionate Shower'

A contest entry

    : , Your review:

    Comment Suggestion: What is your your first impression?
    Line numbers  • Invite them to read
    : no Cost: 0 free left 0 points, You have (?)

Comments

1 - 12 of 12

  • abuyi
    January 24, 2008
    Edit | Reply
    imagery is wonderfull.. thanks for entering and best of luck


  • amaranthine lover gold member
    January 10, 2008

    Edit | Reply

    ***

    I extremely liked this, there was a dulcet tone about it, very fluidic and the imagery was very real to me, I could picture it completely, thanks for entering

  • tara wilson gold member
    December 29, 2007
    Edit | Reply
    this is beautiful...it's very creative..every line is amazing, I can totally see her playing it, and it touches on all the senses!!


  • Lute
    December 26, 2007
    Edit | Reply
    content 7.3
    vocabulary 9
    accuracy 7.4
    creativity 7.5
    theme 7.8
    originality 7.5

    totals: 46.5


  • trista gold member
    December 18, 2007

    Edit | Reply
    I can't say that I hated your format, but my question is...why? I'd say you must have had some reason behind it, and I'm very curious what your intentions were. Some of the staggered lines might have been effective, but in general I think this would do much better left aligned.

    There's something about your poem that highly appeals to me. Your theme wasn't completely clear to me just from reading the poem, but I think most of that comes from the capitalization and punctuation. Working on those would help guide your readers through your thoughts a little more and maybe quite possibly improve the flow to perfection.

    The imagery is wonderful. I especially loved your description of her fingernails. I still have a few entries to go, but I will say this is going to earn the only full 10 points I've given in imagery for this PO contest thus far.

    You have a very well rounded entry, with no major deductions in any category that would bring the score down. I don't recall seeing you in the PO contests before, but I do hope you'll join us again, especially in the POY coming soon.

    Good luck and best wishes,
    ~J.


  • ZachP gold member
    December 18, 2007

    Edit | Reply

    Hmm... I'm not very fond of the capping

    and I'm definately not fond of the format.

     

    But other than that??

     

    This was a pretty good write :) I love the images that you paint and the comparisions that you drew. Some punctuation stuffs, as E'lodie pointed out, and I agree with the title, as well :-)

     

    But over all, this stands out

    which can only be a good sign :)

     

    Good luck

     

    * grammar - 9.7

    * syntax/flow - 9.7

    * understandability - 10

    * uncommon theme - 10

    * overall impression - 9.8

    * effectiveness of title - 9.3

    * ability to hook reader - 9 (the formatting)

    * ability to follow rules - 10

    * presentation / visual appeal - 9.1

    * effective use of poetic devices - 10

    Total: 96.6

     

    OUCH! The hook took you down a good fraction of a point


  • sans.paroles
    December 17, 2007

    Edit | Reply
    Watch out for capping every line! It's generally a no-no.
    I have to agree with bear that I originally was turned off by the spacing, but I don't hate it on the 2nd or 3rd read.
    I would have liked a bit more punctuation, saw some errors here and there.
    I can see where you were trying to go with the title, but I really feel that a piece like this should be topped with something more creative.
    The one thing I would work on is drawing in more emotions. How did each of these girls FEEL when playing the guitar? How did that change over time? etc. I can see a good deal of potential!
    So many great images coming through here, like the juxtaposition of the girl's reverence with her bright orange pick, or the profile of porcelain. The phrase "Dripping from the guitar" was pure magic!
    This will do quite nicely on my scoreboard


  • cutiepie gold member
    December 17, 2007

    Edit | Reply
    I loved the format is is shouted "idealistic" to me. Your notes added the timeless element, good luck in the contest


  • Jornada
    December 17, 2007

    Edit | Reply

    Timeless

    Insightful combination of now and long ago--what we are on the outside and what our soul says inside. It is reassuring, and the imagery evokes a smile of pleasure, whichever time.


  • islekine gold member
    December 17, 2007
    Edit | Reply

    Beautifully penned....

    Best wishes in the contest!
    Write on!
    *PEACE*


  • Arkbear gold member
    December 17, 2007

    Edit | Reply

    Beautiful ~

    When I first saw this entry, I went.....OY!!......as the Fromat is NOT one which I would choose.........

     

    ......but, you penned this so well, that I enjoyed it even more the second time around ~

     

    A splendid job on bringing me into your monitor and wanting to read more!

     

    This is in the Top entries thus far ~

     

    Whether or not it scores well on the board is another question, as it depends on the areas which I look at ~

     

    I Really enjoyed your Theme!

     

    I give you Props for making me believe in this entry and everything you penned ~

     

    A wonderful balance of *Show & Tell* to comfort the Readers senses in every detail ~

     

    One thing I am NOT a fan of, is the Capping of every single line, as the FLOW is completely fumbled, IMO ~

     

    Other than that, I think I am more anxious than you to see how this scores on my Board....let's see, shall we?

     

    Good luck with your entry and your talents,

     

    Bear ~

     

    Title   9.85

    Flow   9.7

    Depth   9.95

    Theme   10

    Feelings   9.75

    Grammar   9.85

    Presentation 9.85

    Uncommonness  10

    Sit & Ponder Affect  9.8

    Ability to follow Rules  10

    Bears Score:  98.75

    Nice job!

1 - 12 of 12